Pacers vs Thunder Free Pick, Analysis, Game Preview

Pacers +9.5: A Classic Bounce-Back Spot Backed by Data

Let’s be clear right away—we had OKC covering in Game 4, and we cashed. We even put out content beforehand flagging Scott Foster’s assignment, jokingly (or not) warning that “The Extender” might be in play. And like clockwork, the final minutes were filled with questionable whistles that helped OKC pull away. While we’re glad the cover hit, it’s hard to argue that the way it unfolded wasn’t flukey. That ending shaped the public’s view, and as a result, we’re now looking at an inflated -9.5 line for Game 5.

This is a classic market overreaction—and Indiana thrives in spots like this. In fact, they’ve arguably played their best basketball on the road, already beating OKC in Game 1 as a visitor. This is a loose, fast-paced team that seems to play freer away from the pressure of their home crowd. And the data backs it up.

Let’s start with a macro playoff trend. Over the past five postseasons (excluding Round 1), playoff underdogs of +8 or more have covered the spread at a 66% rate (25-13). If you zoom in further to Games 4, 5, and 6—when series narratives are well-established and lines tend to overreact—you get a 77% cover rate (10-3) with a 48% ROI. We exclude Round 1 because blowouts and mismatches are more common early, often skewing the numbers. These mid-series games are where dogs stay scrappy.

Now let’s look at the three core systems all flashing green for Indiana:

1. Bounce-Back Underdogs in High-Total Games
   Over the past 3 seasons, teams that didn’t cover their previous game, are now underdogs, and are playing in a game with a total of 210+ have gone 50-23-1 ATS (69%), including 18-7 (72%) this year for a 38% ROI.
   👉 Why it makes sense: High-total games imply pace and volatility, which give underdogs more chances to stay close or sneak in a backdoor cover—especially after a prior letdown. When the market fades them after a non-cover, value opens up.
2. Off a Home Loss, Now on the Road
   All-time in the playoffs, teams that just lost at home and are now on the road have gone 122-83-2 ATS (60%). Over the last four seasons, that number sharpens to 32-14 (70%) with a 33% ROI—and it’s 9-5 ATS (64%) this year.
   👉 Why it makes sense: These teams tend to come out focused after letting one slip at home, and the spread often reflects that prior home failure a little too strongly.
3. Rick Carlisle: Elite in Road Bounce-Back Spots
   Carlisle is 69-55 ATS (56%) in the playoffs overall—but when his team is coming off a loss and also playing on the road, that jumps to 19-8-1 ATS (70%).
   👉 Why it makes sense: Carlisle adjusts well after losses, and road games allow his squad to block out distractions and reset mentally. His experience is a clear edge in these moments.

The Pacers’ Current Form Supports the Play

They’re 13-7 ATS (65%) in the 2024 postseason, and an even better 7-3 ATS (70%) on the road. Narrow it down to road games following a loss or non-cover, and they’re a perfect 3-0 ATS.

So yes, OKC might take the W tonight—but history, systems, and situational value say Indiana keeps it close. We’re backing the Pacers +9.5.

For more of our best bets posted every single day to our bets dashbord, click below and join Insider Bets!