Written by: Jake Turner
Jake is a veteran sports analyst with over 10 years of MLB prop betting experience.
Yankees vs Orioles: Betting Preview & Props (Sep 19)
Last updated: September 19, 2025Game Time: 9/19, 07:05PM
Game Preview
As the New York Yankees travel to face the Baltimore Orioles, all eyes are on the pivotal pitching matchups and how each lineup will handle the opposing arms. Despite the lack of available betting odds, the game promises intriguing dynamics, with both teams showcasing unique strengths and vulnerabilities.
Pitching Preview
Pitching Matchup: Will Warren (NYY) vs Trevor Rogers (BAL)
Will Warren (NYY):
- Arsenal: Four-Seam Fastball (41% usage, 93.3 mph), Sinker (22% usage, 93.2 mph), Sweeper (21% usage, 82.7 mph), Changeup (10% usage, 87.0 mph), Curveball (7% usage, 80.0 mph)
Will Warren brings a balanced mix of pitches, favoring velocity but also leveraging movement with his sweeper and curveball. The Baltimore lineup, averaging .239 this season, is projected for a .240 xBA against Warren's diverse arsenal.
Trevor Rogers (BAL):
- Arsenal: Four-Seam Fastball (40% usage, 93.1 mph), Changeup (25% usage, 86.2 mph), Sinker (15% usage, 92.9 mph), Slider (12% usage, 81.1 mph), Sweeper (8% usage, 78.1 mph)
Trevor Rogers relies heavily on his fastball and changeup combination, aiming to disrupt timing. The Yankees lineup has averaged .271 this season but is expected to dip slightly to a .264 xBA against Rogers' pitch selections.
Lineup Matchups
Lineup Matchups & Batting Edges
For the Yankees vs Trevor Rogers:
- The Yankees lineup averages .271 this season but projects to .264 vs Rogers' arsenal.
- Biggest Increase: Amed Rosario: Season BA .287 → xBA vs arsenal .310 (+23 points), Season K% 14.4% → Arsenal K% 9.6% (-4.8%)
- Biggest Decrease: Ben Rice: Season BA .287 → xBA vs arsenal .235 (-52 points), Season K% 22.3% → Arsenal K% 29.4% (+7.1%)
For the Orioles vs Will Warren:
- The Orioles lineup averages .238 this season but projects to .240 vs Warren's arsenal.
- Biggest Increase: Samuel Basallo: Season BA .188 → xBA vs arsenal .264 (+76 points), Season K% 21.7% → Arsenal K% 17.1% (-4.6%)
- Biggest Decrease: Dylan Beavers: Season BA .277 → xBA vs arsenal .225 (-52 points), Season K% 23.8% → Arsenal K% 30.2% (+6.4%)
Whiff Outlook
Strikeout Risks & Rewards
For the Yankees:
- The Yankees' projected K-rate is 23.0% vs Trevor Rogers — up 0.3% from their 22.7% season average, suggesting minimal change in strikeout potential.
For the Orioles:
- The Orioles' projected K-rate is 26.7% vs Will Warren — up 2.2% from their 24.4% season average, indicating a moderate increase in strikeout risk.
Umpire Impact
Behind the Plate: Umpire assignment has not been announced, which makes prop volatility a concern.
What to Bet On
📢 Prop Alert: Samuel Basallo (.188 → .264, +76 points) meets betting lean criteria!
No significant K prop alerts met our threshold for this matchup.
🔑 Key Takeaways
- Samuel Basallo presents a significant batting prop opportunity with a notable increase in xBA against Warren.
- While the Yankees' strikeout rates show little change, the Orioles face a higher strikeout risk against Warren.
- Umpire assignment is currently unknown, adding an element of unpredictability to the game.
- Overall, focus on individual batter props rather than strikeout props due to uncertain umpire impact.
🧠 FAQs
Q: Who is the best betting prop for the Yankees vs Orioles game? A: Samuel Basallo shows a strong statistical edge, making him a prime candidate for betting props.
Q: Is the umpire a pitcher-friendly umpire? A: Umpire assignment is TBA, creating uncertainty in the game's officiating impact.
Q: What time is the Yankees vs Orioles game? A: The game is scheduled for 9/19, 07:05PM.
---
Want more of our best props and betting analysis? Click below and join insider bets!
---
