Written by: Ryan Chen
Ryan combines advanced statistics with traditional scouting to identify profitable betting opportunities.
Jays vs Royals: Betting Preview & Props (Sep 19)
Last updated: September 19, 2025Game Time: 9/19, 07:40PM
Today's Setup
The Toronto Blue Jays take on the Kansas City Royals in a key matchup that sees them as a −144 favorite according to DraftKings. With 95% of the money backing the Jays, they are the popular choice against the Royals, who sit as +118 underdogs. Both teams are navigating through their respective rotations, hoping for a strong performance from their starters.
Pitcher Breakdown
Pitching Matchup: Max Scherzer vs Michael Lorenzen
Max Scherzer (TOR):
Scherzer brings a classic power-pitcher profile with his arsenal: Four-Seam Fastball (48% usage, 93.6 mph), Slider (23% usage, 86.4 mph), Changeup (14% usage, 84.9 mph), Curveball (12% usage, 76.7 mph), and Cutter (3% usage, 87.7 mph). Known for his velocity-heavy approach, Scherzer's mix is designed to miss bats, though he faces a Royals lineup that averages .2449 this season, with a projected xBA of .2538 against his arsenal.
Michael Lorenzen (KC):
Lorenzen offers a varied pitch mix: Four-Seam Fastball (22% usage, 94.1 mph), Sinker (18% usage, 93.1 mph), Changeup (17% usage, 83.9 mph), Slider (12% usage, 85.2 mph), Curveball (12% usage, 82.2 mph), Cutter (11% usage, 90.3 mph), and Sweeper (8% usage, 82.4 mph). As a pitch-mix artist, Lorenzen's challenge will be against a Toronto lineup that averages .2701 this season, but projects to a slightly lower .2676 against his offerings.
Lineup Matchups
Lineup Matchups & Batting Edges
For Toronto vs Michael Lorenzen:
- The Blue Jays lineup averages .2701 this season but projects to .2676 against Lorenzen's arsenal.
- Biggest Increase: Jr. Guerrero: Season BA .300 → xBA vs arsenal .320 (+20 points), Season K% 13.4% → Arsenal K% 14.3% (+0.9%)
- Biggest Decrease: Davis Schneider: Season BA .246 → xBA vs arsenal .190 (−56 points), Season K% 27.9% → Arsenal K% 30.8% (+2.9%)
For Kansas City vs Max Scherzer:
- The Royals lineup averages .2449 this season but projects to .2538 against Scherzer's arsenal.
- Biggest Increase: Jac Caglianone: Season BA .154 → xBA vs arsenal .261 (+107 points), Season K% 21.4% → Arsenal K% 20.4% (−1.0%)
- Biggest Decrease: Maikel Garcia: Season BA .289 → xBA vs arsenal .196 (−93 points), Season K% 12.5% → Arsenal K% 47.1% (+34.6%)
Contact vs Strikeout Profile
Strikeout Risks & Rewards
- The Blue Jays' projected K-rate is 18.5% vs Lorenzen — down 0.2% from their 18.7% season average.
- The Royals' projected K-rate is 22.8% vs Scherzer — up 4.9% from their 18.0% season average.
Umpire Influence
Behind the Plate: Umpire assignment has not been announced, which makes prop volatility a concern.
What to Bet On
📢 Prop Alert: Jr. Guerrero (.300 → .320, +20 points) meets betting lean criteria!
⚡ K Prop Alert: Max Scherzer strikeout OVER - Royals' K-rate jumps to 22.8% vs this arsenal!
🔑 Key Takeaways
- Jr. Guerrero shows a positive batting edge against Lorenzen, indicating a strong batting prop opportunity.
- Max Scherzer has a favorable strikeout projection against a Royals lineup with an increased K-rate.
- Jac Caglianone shows a massive batting advantage, although his overall performance variance might temper expectations.
- Umpire assignment remains unannounced, introducing uncertainty in prop bets.
🧠 FAQs
Q: Who is the best betting prop for the TOR vs KC game? A: Jr. Guerrero meets our betting lean criteria with a significant projected improvement in batting average.
Q: Is the umpire a pitcher-friendly umpire? A: Umpire assignment has not been announced, making this factor uncertain.
Q: What time is the TOR vs KC game? A: The game is scheduled for 9/19, 07:40PM.
---
Want more of our best props and betting analysis? Click below and join insider bets!
---
