Written by: Michael Rivera
Michael is a data-driven baseball enthusiast who specializes in pitch analytics and betting trends.
Cardinals vs Brewers: Betting Preview & Props (Sep 12)
Last updated: September 12, 2025
Game Time: 9/12, 08:10PM
Game Preview
The St. Louis Cardinals face off against the Milwaukee Brewers in a pivotal matchup at American Family Field. The Brewers are strong favorites, with DraftKings listing them at -187 and the Cardinals as +152 underdogs, backed by 91% of the public money. With intriguing pitching matchups and lineup dynamics, this game offers several betting angles for savvy bettors.
Rotation Report
Pitching Matchup: Andre Pallante vs Quinn Priester
Andre Pallante (STL):
- Arsenal: Four-Seam Fastball (44% usage, 94.5 mph), Slider (29% usage, 87.5 mph), Curveball (13% usage, 78.2 mph), Sinker (13% usage, 95.0 mph), Sweeper (0% usage, 85.0 mph)
Andre Pallante is a velocity-heavy pitcher, utilizing his fastball and sinker to overpower hitters while mixing in breaking balls like his slider and curveball. The Brewers lineup averages .260 this season, with a projected xBA of .265 against Pallante's arsenal.
Quinn Priester (MIL):
- Arsenal: Sinker (43% usage, 93.8 mph), Slider (27% usage, 86.0 mph), Cutter (19% usage, 92.3 mph), Curveball (9% usage, 80.8 mph), Changeup (2% usage, 88.4 mph)
Quinn Priester boasts a comprehensive pitch mix, relying heavily on his sinker and slider, complemented by a cutter and occasional curveball. The Cardinals lineup averages .251 this season and projects to .259 against Priester's arsenal.
Lineup Advantage vs Arsenal
Lineup Matchups & Batting Edges
For the Cardinals vs Quinn Priester:
- The Cardinals lineup averages .251 this season but projects to .259 against Priester's arsenal.
- Biggest Increase: Nolan Gorman: Season BA .216 → xBA vs arsenal .272 (+56 points), Season K% 31.9% → Arsenal K% 24.9% (-7.0%)
- Biggest Decrease: Iván Herrera: Season BA .279 → xBA vs arsenal .237 (-42 points), Season K% 19.3% → Arsenal K% 21.6% (+2.3%)
For the Brewers vs Andre Pallante:
- The Brewers lineup averages .260 this season but projects to .265 against Pallante's arsenal.
- Biggest Increase: Andrew Vaughn: Season BA .248 → xBA vs arsenal .307 (+59 points), Season K% 18.2% → Arsenal K% 17.1% (-1.1%)
- Biggest Decrease: Brice Turang: Season BA .289 → xBA vs arsenal .261 (-28 points), Season K% 22.3% → Arsenal K% 24.3% (+2.0%)
Lineup Strikeout Trends vs Arsenal
Strikeout Risks & Rewards
- Cardinals: Projected K-rate is 17.4% vs Priester — down 5.1% from their 22.4% season average, indicating potential contact advantage.
- Brewers: Projected K-rate is 20.8% vs Pallante — up 1.7% from their 19.0% season average, suggesting slightly increased strikeout risk.
Umpire Influence
Behind the Plate: Umpire assignment has not been announced, which makes prop volatility a concern.
What to Bet On
📢 Prop Alert: José Fermín (.250 → .297, +47 points) meets betting lean criteria!
⚡ K Prop Alert: No strikeout prop opportunities meet our betting threshold in this matchup.
🔑 Key Takeaways
- José Fermín presents a strong batting prop opportunity with a significant projected increase in batting average.
- No significant strikeout prop opportunities due to lack of a substantial K-rate spike.
- Umpire assignment is pending, adding uncertainty to props reliant on umpire tendencies.
- Betting recommendation leans towards exploiting the Cardinals' improved contact rate against Priester.
🧠 FAQs
Q: Who is the best betting prop for the Cardinals vs Brewers game? A: José Fermín meets our strict betting criteria with a notable increase in expected batting average.
Q: Is the umpire a pitcher-friendly umpire? A: Umpire assignment has not been announced, which makes prop volatility a concern.
Q: What time is the Cardinals vs Brewers game? A: The game is scheduled for 9/12, 08:10PM.
---
Want more of our best props and betting analysis? Click below and join insider bets!
---
