September 5, 2025

Game Preview

Written by: David Mitchell

David has been analyzing MLB matchups and umpire tendencies for professional bettors since 2018.

Brewers vs Pirates: Betting Preview & Props (Sep 05)

Last updated: September 05, 2025

Game Time: 9/5, 06:40PM

Game Overview

The Milwaukee Brewers head to Pittsburgh to face the Pirates in what promises to be an intriguing matchup. With the Brewers favored at -158 and 88% of the money backing them, they are expected to dominate. The Pirates, despite being the +129 underdogs, will look to upset their divisional rivals on home turf.

Rotation Report

Pitching Matchup: Quinn Priester vs Johan Oviedo

Quinn Priester (MIL):

Priester offers a five-pitch mix with a sinker-heavy repertoire: Sinker (43% usage, 93.8 mph), Slider (28% usage, 86.0 mph), Cutter (18% usage, 92.3 mph), Curveball (9% usage, 80.8 mph), and Changeup (2% usage, 88.4 mph). His arsenal leans towards inducing ground balls and keeping hitters off balance. The Pirates lineup averages .254 this season with a projected xBA of .265 against Priester’s arsenal.

Johan Oviedo (PIT):

Oviedo complements his power game with a diverse set of pitches: Four-Seam Fastball (38% usage, 95.2 mph), Slider (33% usage, 87.1 mph), Curveball (15% usage, 77.6 mph), Sinker (10% usage, 95.4 mph), and Changeup (4% usage, 88.2 mph). This mix should challenge the Brewers, who boast a season average of .256 but project to a slightly higher .262 xBA against Oviedo’s pitches.

Lineup Matchups

Lineup Matchups & Batting Edges

For Brewers vs Johan Oviedo: The Brewers lineup averages .256 this season but projects to .262 against Oviedo’s arsenal.

Biggest Increase: Andrew Vaughn: Season BA .240 → xBA vs arsenal .310 (+70 points), Season K% 18.2% → Arsenal K% 16.5% (-1.7%)
Biggest Decrease: Brice Turang: Season BA .291 → xBA vs arsenal .255 (-36 points), Season K% 22.1% → Arsenal K% 25.1% (+3.0%)

For Pirates vs Quinn Priester: The Pirates lineup averages .254 this season and projects a .265 xBA against Priester's offerings.

Biggest Increase: Andrew McCutchen: Season BA .245 → xBA vs arsenal .297 (+52 points), Season K% 21.9% → Arsenal K% 22.6% (+0.7%)
Biggest Decrease: Joey Bart: Season BA .249 → xBA vs arsenal .217 (-32 points), Season K% 27.3% → Arsenal K% 27.9% (+0.6%)

Whiff Outlook

Strikeout Risks & Rewards

The Brewers' projected K-rate is 22.2% vs Oviedo — up 2.2% from their 20.0% season average.
The Pirates' projected K-rate is 22.3% vs Priester — down 0.2% from their 22.5% season average.

Plate Umpire Analysis

Behind the Plate: Umpire assignment has not been announced, which makes prop volatility a concern.

What to Bet On

📢 Prop Alert: Andrew Vaughn (.240 → .310, +70 points) meets betting lean criteria!

No significant strikeout prop opportunities arise as neither team shows a K-rate increase over 25% with a 4% jump.

🔑 Key Takeaways

Andrew Vaughn projects significant improvement against Oviedo, making him a key batter prop.
No standout strikeout prop opportunities due to moderate projected K-rate changes.
Umpire assignment remains unknown, adding uncertainty to prop bets.
The Brewers are heavily favored, but the Pirates have potential batting advantages against Priester.

🧠 FAQs

Q: Who is the best betting prop for the MIL vs PIT game? A: Andrew Vaughn demonstrates significant batting potential with a projected xBA boost against Johan Oviedo.

Q: Is the umpire a pitcher-friendly umpire? A: Umpire assignment is yet to be announced, leaving this question unanswered for now.

Q: What time is the MIL vs PIT game? A: The game is scheduled for 9/5, 06:40PM.

---

Want more of our best props and betting analysis? Click below and join insider bets!

See all our best bets daily!

---